Available Now
Mentmore · New Mexico
A rental home that treats you like more than a tenant — that's the standard we set every day.
At Ishmael Rental Properties, we believe renting should feel as straightforward as it sounds. No hidden fees, no ghosting when something breaks, no surprises at renewal time. Just honest listings, responsive maintenance, and landlords who actually show up.
15+
Properties Managed
98%
Tenant Retention
24h
Maintenance Response
About Us
We built this company on a simple belief: renting a home shouldn't require a fight.
Ishmael Rental Properties was founded in Mentmore with a straightforward mission — to give renters a better experience and to give property owners peace of mind. Too many people treat rentals as transactions. We treat them as homes.
Every property in our portfolio is personally inspected, professionally maintained, and honestly advertised. When you apply with us, you get a real person on the other end of the phone. When something needs fixing, you won't spend weeks waiting for a reply. When your lease is up, you'll know exactly what to expect.
We serve tenants and landlords across Mentmore and the surrounding community. Whether you're looking for a quiet apartment downtown, a family home near the schools, or a low-maintenance condo, we match people with places that actually fit their lives.
Transparent Terms
No fine-print tricks. Every fee, every rule, every detail spelled out before you sign.
Clear Contracts
Leases written in plain language so you know exactly what you're committing to.
Responsive Support
Real humans answer your calls and address issues within 24 hours, guaranteed.
Current Listings
Homes available now in Mentmore
Each property is photographed in person and listed with accurate details. What you see is what you get.
Available Now
Most Requested
New listings are added regularly. Contact us to be notified when something matching your criteria becomes available.
How It Works
From inquiry to move-in in four straightforward steps
Tell Us What You Need
Call us, email us, or fill out the form below. Share your budget, preferred neighborhood, and must-haves — we'll listen before we suggest anything.
See the Property in Person
We schedule a tour at a time that works for you. No pressure, no rush. If the place doesn't feel right, we'll find another one.
Sign with Confidence
Our lease is written in plain English. We walk you through every clause so there are zero surprises once you move in.
Move In and Settle Down
Keys in hand, home ready. If anything comes up after you're settled, you text or call a real person — not a hotline that goes nowhere.
Tenant Stories
What people say about living with us
I've rented from a few places in Mentmore over the years, and Ishmael Rental Properties is the first company where I never once felt like I was being pushed around. They show up when they say they will, and they fix things without making you chase them.
The apartment I found through them was exactly as described — same photos, same condition, same price. No bait and switch, no last-minute fees. I knew what I was getting, and that's rare in this market.
As a property owner, I appreciate that they take care of my unit like it's their own. Maintenance requests get handled quickly, and I get clear reports every month. It's the kind of partnership that makes rental ownership actually enjoyable.
Ready to find a rental that actually feels like home?
Call us at (505) 722-6535 or send a message below. We respond the same business day.
Get in Touch
We'd love to hear from you
Whether you're looking for a place to rent, considering listing your property with us, or just have a question — reach out. We answer every call and message during business hours.
- Office Address
-
13 Alpha St
Mentmore, NM 87319 - Phone
- (505) 722-6535
- Office Hours
-
Monday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday – Sunday: By appointment
Message Sent
Thank you for reaching out. A member of our team will get back to you within one business day.
